best amish restaurants in ohio

All owned by the Howard Miller family. Logan, OH It was my FAVORITE place for traditional Amish cooking. We love the one in Yoder, KS, just outside of Hutchinson, KS. Shom, on baseball, I cant imagine how exhausting it must be to go through 162 games, gut-wrenching come from behinds in the playoffs, go all the way to game 7, then lose. Twice a year I spend 5-6 days in Shipshewana for a quilt retreat, and I always drive to the Essenhaus for dinner no matter what. She looked at that can for a moment, then said, Why not? After that, pork and noodles was a semi-regular thing at our house, too. I have not had any food there that I didnt like. The Little-Known Park In Ohio That Transforms Into An Ice Palace In The Winter, The Scenic North Coast Route That Leads To 5 Ohio Lighthouses, Theres Nothing More Enchanting Than A Winter Getaway To This Ohio Small Town, With An Abandoned Blast Furnace And 2,983 Acres To Explore, This Underrated Ohio State Park Is A Must-Visit, The Largest Quilt Barn In Ohio Is Truly A Sight To See, The Unique Tour That Will Take You Deep Into Ohio Amish Country Like Never Before, This Charming Little Farm Town In Ohio Is The Perfect Place To Get Away From It All, 9 Ohio Amish Country Restaurants With Food So Good Youll Be Back For Seconds. It is located at 8101 State Route 241, Mt. 30 just east of Lancaster. And they have entertainment in the summer. Mrs.Yoders Kitchen, Mt. For more information, Walnut Creek Cheese, 2641 OH-39, Walnut Creek, OH 44687, USA, For some of the best old-fashioned cooking in Ohio, be sure to check out this Amish Country gem. 330 893 4600 Walnut Creek Ohio Sugarcreek Ohio Middlebury Indiana Sarasota Florida Bellville Ohio Plain City Ohio Berlin Ohio Theater have to be Yoders down it pinecraft, the little retirement settlement in Sarasota Florida. Free samples are available throughout the store to try and enjoy before buying! Nearly a century later, this restaurant still serves an amazing cup of coffee for only 75 cents. Oh, the chocolate fondue. false : open">, Holmes County Chamber of Commerce & Tourism Bureau. The Amish Door Restaurant We love eat at Katies Kitchen in Ronks, PA- Amish owned and operated. Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for 1980s Pain & Fancy Family Amish County Restaurant Menu New Philadelphia Ohio at the best online prices at eBay! One of the, Shisler's Cheese House, 55 Kidron Rd, Orrville, OH 44667, USA. 888 264 7436 (330)893-3786 Indiana, and also in one in Daviess County, Indiana. Cheap and basic food, homemade. Amish Door Restaurant 1210 Winesburg St., Wilmot, OH 44689 The Amish Door Village is a triple threat in Amish Countryeat, sleep and shop. The best hidden gems and little known destinations - straight to your inbox. Dinner Buffet - Thursday - Saturday. Lots of history and things to see in the area. That is less common. You'll find Dutch Kitchen in this restored farmhouse, which was built in 1858. Kidron Town & Country Restaurant Pull up a seat at our table and share with us. While there, but sure to allow time to observe the cheese making process through their factory viewing windows, Monday-Friday from 8am to 12pm. Meals prepared both by Amish and non-Amish cooks. Valerie, 330 857 2131 Boyds opens at 5:30 am which is perfect to have a hearty breakfast before the work day starts. What are the best Amish restaurants in Ohio? There were long tables pushed together, and we chatted with strangers as we waited. Strawberry shortcake and homemade pies are among Boyd & Wurthmanns most popular desserts! (330)359-5464 Peach cream pie cools on the counter. d) They yell out Is this yours?, or I kind of forgot about Breitenbach! Hope (How does a man know which hat to leave with when he hangs them on the hat rack, they all look the same?) Hope Ohio Amish style flavors mixed with American cuisine. morning breakfast buffet. amzn_assoc_title = "Shop Related Products"; Have you been to any of these country restaurants in Ohio before? Coblentz Chocolate Call ahead before visiting: 330-893-2550.*. It's located at 6262 OH 245, North Lewisburg, OH 43060. I just love their Noodles over Mash, which is no longer written on the menu but they will make it for you if you ask. In the morning, you can greet the day with. Reserve a table for the best dining in Berlin, Ohio on TripAdvisor: and produce" 09/30/2018; "Great Stop On Your Amish Adventure" 09/30/2018. Der Dutchman Do try Beachys Country Chalet Restaurant in Sugarcreek OH. Where is Reihls Place and Zooks- location?- We have spent time in that area of Pa for the last 4 years and have not discovered them. Laurareally a great story. I have travelled to many amish/menonnite areas, and my favorites are: There is also a Zooks Motel in Lancaster but not an Amish place. I do have a friend who is Mennonite and her food is delicious. 1. With more than 10 years of writing experience and a background in news reporting for Ohio newspapers, she's published pieces in multiple print and online publications. The restaurant has been cooking up the most delicious comfort food since 1993. Absolutely give this place a try if you are in the area! (Please note: GPS and cell phone service may be limited.) I?ve never been to Ohio?s Amish country but man, do some of those places sound good! Deli meats and cheeses as well as farm-fresh produce are also part of the inventory. 12 Restaurants in Millersburg | 3,895 restaurants available on OpenTable; 13 Walnut Creek Ohio Amish Country Restaurants | The Wallhouse Hotel; 14 A Culinary Heaven in Holmes County | Ohio. How about youwhats your favorite Amish restaurant? This delectable spread tastes amazing on fresh, warm bread. My favorite part of this restaurant is the experience, atmosphere, and the views from the dining room. None of the restaurants can really beat home cooking, of course. After a hearty dinner, remember to stop by the The Amish Door Bakery. It says a lot that Amish people actually eat there. No matter what you order, youll be impressed. This Stunning Lodge Offers An Affordable, Resort-Level Getaway In One Of Ohios Most Beautiful State Parks, Youll Swear Youre Dining In A European Bistro When You Visit This Cafe In Small Town Ohio, The Little-Known Park In Ohio That Transforms Into An Ice Palace In The Winter, The Scenic North Coast Route That Leads To 5 Ohio Lighthouses, 12 Hidden Gems Along The Ohio Countryside That Are So Worth The Drive, The Awesome Store Every Ohioan Should Tour At Least Once, Why People Go Crazy For This One Pie In Small Town Ohio, The Gigantic Fruit Spread Store In Ohio Youll Want To Visit Over And Over Again, unique hardware store in the middle of nowhere, Tis The Season Christmas Shoppe in Millersburg, this road trip to the best Amish country stores. Where do you go in Ohio when youre craving Amish food near me? Share your thoughts with us in the comments below! This was a good topic to refer back to when traveling, thanks Erik! With more than 10 years of writing experience and a background in news reporting for Ohio newspapers, she's published pieces in multiple print and online publications. And the entrees are huge!more. Remember that dining here is not all about the noodles (its just a little about the noodles). (adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({}); Scripps School of Journalism. Get even more stories delivered right to your email. Even if lunch is light, theres time to lean back with coworkers while chatting over trail bologna and swiss sandwiches. Kauffman's Country Bakery Millersburg 1.2 mi away. Ive never had a burger at Boyd & Wurthmann- will try that next time. These are both on the National Road and the Casselman Bridge is right by the Penn Alps. The ice cream shop is no more. How do you know its an Amish place? Enjoy good food with friends & family. But I definitely visit the more conventional places as well. Formerly Grandmas Homestead Restaurant. I was really disappointed. 6. Business located in Kidron Town & Country Market. 1210 Winesburg St. Menu items including Spaetzle, a traditional German soup, winzersalat, bratwurst sandwich, or Hackbratentorte meatloaf in crust. Many tables were full of Amish out for dinner. Not responsible for changes to the above information. ),youll also find lots of opportunities to stop and enjoy a bit of the local culture. I didnt know about Amish like I do now from you Erik, and Richard and Kevin. What I do remember was the shoofly pie! In the Elkhart/Lagrange Counties area, I like Village Inn in Sorry to report Stolzfus Farm family rest has closed. Best amish restaurants in Berlin, Ohio, autumn 2022 - Restaurant Guru. (Its at the corner of US 20 and State Road 5.). Cant go wrong with anything on the menu ! Check out our top picks for Things to do in Amish County Ohio for more ideas and inspiration. Ashery Country Store: How to get there and what to expect! The newer locations dining room includes a sweeping view over a valley of farmland, making this one of the most nostalgic places to eat in Holmes County. My favorite at Bags is the Chicken Parmesan Sandwich on a pretzel bun (pictured below), while my husband adores the Jalapeno Burger. The following are 8 country restaurants in Ohio that are so worth the trip. Amish-style food abounds in Ohio, especially in the tourist-friendly Holmes County community, with over a dozen restaurants serving dishes under the Amish or PA Dutch banner. Luckily, weve pinpointed three of the best Amish restaurants in Ohio! Starting as a grocery store in the 1930s, Boyd & Wurthmann Restaurant has grown in to a local favorite place for home-style Amish cooking. Looking for the best places to eat when visiting Ohios Amish Country? If your in the Big Valley area of Central PA you have to stop by A.J. amzn_assoc_ad_mode = "search"; Its every bit as good now as it was the first time we ate there. Whenever we go home we try to eat there. Discover the best things to do with your family and make memories that will last a lifetime! Thank you! Read More about the many dining options available in Holmes County, Ohio. The large market includes a sliced-to-order deli, special recipe meat shop, Amish and Mennonite local grown fruits and vegetables, made-from-scratch bakery, and on site cannery with jams, jellies, sauces and more. is absolutely marvellous- especially if you want to eat where the locals eat. Olde World Bakery & Bistro is located at 4363 SR 39 E, Berlin, OH. thevalleymarketplace.com Weve got the broasted chicken and the green beans steaming. Open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner buffets, this delicious Amish Country restaurant offers all your favorite country style dishes. Tucked into the woods behind the inn, our log cabins offer luxurious privacy and seclusion for your vacation. Im all about those cheese samples at Heinis. The othermore, American (Traditional)Breakfast & BrunchBuffets$$, I still prefer the larger Amish restaurants, but this was a nice change!more, American (Traditional)BakeriesBreakfast & Brunch$$, There are few truly Amish restaurants in Amish Country, most are tourist traps and cater to themore, It's not a bad Amish restaurant, but not nearly one of my favorites. Gather your strength from sharing the slow-cooked goodness and the fresh-made friendships. And, its off the beaten path where we enjoy our Amish journey the best any other new Amish restaurants besides Katies in that area due to elderly parents illness we have been unable to travel to Lancaster area in last 10 or so months. Amish Country Donuts Donut Shops Coffee Shops Restaurants (15) Website (330) 852-5214 522 Dover Rd NE Sugarcreek, OH 44681 2. Website. Yes its both the food and the atmosphere. You'll find it at 623 Old State Rd., Clarksville, OH 45113. Mrs. Yoders Kitchen is a long time favorite of locals and tourists alike. Weve been having dinner there for approximately 26 years, and the food hasnt changed. To learn more, visit their website, Enjoy authentic Swiss, Austrian and American cuisine in the heart of Holmes County at Guggisberg's Chalet in the Valley. There are exceptions though. Come and experience one of the best Amish restaurants in Ohio! I love Rebeccas (the amazing salads with fruit & poppyseed dressing) and Olde World Caf? If youre looking for organic foods, Ashery Country Store is the place to visit. You will receive your first email soon. 330 482 2236 Peachey & Sons The best We are surrounded by Amish here in PA and this is our absolute favorite place to visit. Its also about sinking into the slowed speed of the country, about appreciating the moment instead of living for the minute. some of these baseball athletes look like they have been to a couple Amish buffet restaurants in their time! Find Amish Country Ohio restaurants. Village of Sugarcreek | Business Association | Fab 50's Fling | Swiss Festival we like it best on Tuesday when they serve the Amish Wedding Meal Have you been to any of the above best Amish restaurants in Ohio before? Also I would say that Chalet In The Valley is more Swiss/German than Amish. I explained a little more in response to Karlas first comment above. DAS is neuter/neutrum, so das Haus = the house, Menus are planned daily to take advantage of the finest produce, meat, and fish available in the area! 22611 Ohio 2 (adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({}); amzn_assoc_placement = "adunit0"; Youll find a large selection of flours, oats, nuts, kernels, berries, soups, beans, spices and more all available in bulk packaging. The interior looks just like grandmas house, and the chicken fried steak cant be beat. DIE is feminine, so die Kche = the kitchen. Der Dutchman 720 State Rte 97 W, Bellville, OH, USA Get Directions Virtual Tour Contact Phone 419-886-7070 Hours Dine-In | Carry-out | Curbside | Delivery Monday - Thursday: 11 am - 7 pm Friday - Saturday: 7 am - 8 pm Bakery Monday - Thursday: 7 am - 7 pm Friday - Saturday: 7 am - 8 pm Follow Us Come and Join Us Light & Delicious Swiss fondue was awesome, and its made with Guggisburg Swiss! For more information, click, Set in an oversized Amish-style home that has a seating capacity of 450, this restaurant is located in Wilmont. Building was torn down, I believe in prep for the new fire station. Millers Dutch Kitchn (CLOSED) Is it savory beef stew and Dutch cabbage rolls? Boyd and Wurthmann Restaurant is located at 4819 East Main St., Berlin, OH 44610. I have never been to an Amish restaurant. The Amish tour train no longer operates. They also offer a line of sugar-free chocolates for those with dietary restrictions. You know that we know how to grow produce in Amish Country. Das Dutch Kitchen Bolivar, OH Thank you for letting me know, Mary Alice. One thing I like is that they often have special local, seasonal items on the menu like dandelion gravy, strawberry shortcake or elderberry pie. Were truly lucky to have the rolling, scenic hills of Amish Country all across the state; and as a result, most of us are just a stones throw from some of the best Amish restaurants in Ohio! Ive gotten the chance to see and possibly sell a machine that produces filtered water and ice. In the morning, you can greet the day with a complimentary country breakfast made from local farm-fresh eggs, and produce and herbs from our own garden. To learn more, visit their website, This award-winning southeast Ohio barbecue joint features a diverse menu, from Louisiana Crab Cakes to slow cooked ribs and pulled pork. Well, much to my surprise, the Michelin Stars article that came out today, named the top 20 Best Food small townsand NONE of them were in Amish areas! Handicap accessible. They feature a breakfast, lunch and dinner menu. Fill your plate. It is confusing, and it took me awhile to distinguish that there is a difference between the Swiss and Amish type of business in the area. It is well worth the trip to experience Sauders. Someone mentioned these two names of restaurants in Lancaster County. Walnut Creek Cheese is located at 2641 State Route 39, When it comes to great shopping, Amish stores in Ohio cant be beat! It's a must-stop before you leave Ohio Amish Country. Large steaming bowls and platters were placed on the tables family style. Berlin, OH, 44610. I would love to visit Amish Country, weve never been. The favorites of my wife and I are Das Dutchman Essenhaus in Middlebury Indiana and Der Dutchman Essenhaus in Walnut Creek Ohio. (330)893-2131 Family Cupboard was my husbands favorite place to eat in Lancaster. Spillway Lodge is an old farmhouse sitting on 128 acres of beautiful, countryside land. But with so many options, how do you decide where to go? Hi Chelsea, and thanks for your suggestions. Charm FamilyRestaurant Believe us, you're going to love this all-you-can-eat Amish buffet In Ohio. Bring your family and loved ones and enjoy a soul-satisfying meal at Colliers. e) They just dont care (they switch hats when they meet again the next day). Its a cute restaurant, too, decorated just like youd expect from the name, and the servers wear pretty authentic costumes, or they used to. At this particular restaurant (Which is Mrs. Yoders, not Millers as I mistakenly wrote) the hat rack is a long horizontal board with pegs-I suppose you could count which # peg your hat is on-. Great service from the time you hit themore, My husband and I got the recommendation to go here from an Amish store owner in Berlin.more, Amish restaurant near Wooster, Ohio! Mrs. Yoder's Kitchen features a hearty buffet, delicious homemade pies, and an at-home atmosphere that we know you'll love. I'm not much for food bars, so I typically order from the menu. Let us know! Their goal is to provide the freshest, tastiest product at a reasonable price with quality, friendly service.. The best hidden gems and little known destinations - straight to your inbox. Their homemade Black Raspberry Cream Pie is a crowd favorite. It's a must-stop before you leave Ohio Amish Country. In the bakery youll find pastries, pies, cookies, donuts, fudge, cakes, breads, and so much more! Too tired of country-style cooking or want a craft beer? Best selection & most expensive), Millers Smorgasboard in Yonks, PA What are the best places to get comfort food in Ohio? In Sarasota, Florida the best is Der Dutchman. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Amish cuisine is rich and hearty. 1015 Edison Street Northwest It is located at 4779 Kidron Rd., Dalton, OH, 44618. Heres a short run-down of German definite articles (singular): You'll find it at 4986 Walnut St, Sugarcreek, OH 44681. Thank you! That is why I asked. 4 - 7pm $19.99. A scribe from that area wrote in this weeks Budget newspaper that Boyds serves free coffee to local residents who are over the age of 80. 108 East Main Street Share it in the comments below. Their fresh salad bar is always appealing, and their menu is full of wonderful options. Hope. It is located at 8101 State Route 241, Mt. Bags is a locally-owned pub with a full bar and daily lunch and dinner specials. As an added bonus, you can get some amazing smoked sausage, beef jerky, Trail Bologna, and more. Food sounds good too, and interesting to hear about another Amish-run place. Its made by an Amish widow who lives a mile north of the cafe. We also enjoy Shady Maple, as well as Yoders and Family Cupboard, All excellent Amish food. Millersburg Brewing has recently expanded to offer a full menu during their business hours Tuesday-Sundays in downtown Millersburg. Learn how your comment data is processed. Best pie around hands down, in my opinion. We would always order the meal family-style and would get large dishes of mashed potatoes, butter homemade egg noodles (YUM! We also frequent Hometown restaurant on Furnace Road when in the area. She doesnt run a restaurant-but if you were at her house during planting or havesting season you think she did with all the workers eating there at meal time. Toll Free: (800) 982-9755, Every so often when Im hunting in Lagrange County, Indiana, I stop at the 5 & 20 restaurant, which has Dutch-style food. Best amish restaurant near me in Mansfield, Ohio Sort:Recommended Price Offers Delivery Offers Takeout Good for Kids Good for Dinner Accepts Credit Cards 1. No problem; the store sells over 2,000 products on its website, which means you can have the taste of Amish Country shipped right to your door. The Farm at Walnut Creek is located at 4147 Co. Rd. Das Essehaus, Middlebury Indiana Barn Restaurant specializes in Amish style home cooking. 330 248 7034 From working Amish farms to one-of-a-kind hardware stores, there are tons of things to do in Ohio Amish Country. Just got back from another little jaunt to Lancaster and have to tell you, we found another great Amish-run place that just might have Katies Kitchen beat! I think the name we give it in the states, national pastime, is about right. 330 893 2550 And youve got to have a wide selection of pies. If you ever happen to see any inside a store in Amish country, dont hesitate to purchase a few jars. You will find all of the best traditional Amish foods here, including real mashed potatoes, homemade bread, and roast beef. Its so popular now there can be lines waiting to get in but well worth the wait. The food is good but I would say leans toward the Swiss/German type of food. Maybe theyll add a stack of buckwheat pancakes and bacon just to keep the company a little longer. 1343 Old Route 39 Das Dutch Kitchen is good. And one way to tell the better ones is by the number of Amish in the place. Wish we had some Amish restaurants in New York State near where I live. Check out these hotels in Walnut Creek, Ohio. Thank you! I hear theres a new one in the Milroy, IN area. Berlin, OH And The Inn At Amish Door provides a comfortable place to stay when visiting the Village and the surrounding Amish Country. Traditional breakfast favorites are served at the break of dawn along with your choice of donuts, fritters, and cinnamon rolls. My daughter was quite envious of her ability to have clothing that fits perfectly since Ive spent my entire life tailoring clothing for her! Their goal is to provide the freshest, tastiest product at a reasonable price with quality, friendly service., 27 Buckeye Street SW, Sugarcreek, OH 44681, 4917 State Route 515, Walnut Creek, OH 44687, Berlin Location: 4727 US 62, Berlin, OH 44610, Walnut Creek Location: 2641 State Route 39, Walnut Creek, OH 44687, 6005 County Road 77, Millersburg, OH 44654, 1210 Winesburg Street, US 62, Wilmot, OH 44689, 4967 Walnut Street, Walnut Creek, OH 44687. Staff is wonderful and the atmosphere is too! Amish homemade style food such as roastedchicken, roast beef, ham, mashed potatoes, stuffing, gravy, corn, green beans, noodles, salad bar, Amish casserole and much more. These sandwiches are served on buttery buns and loaded with fresh toppings. THE 10 BEST Restaurants Near Amish Country in Ohio, United States United States Ohio (OH) Ohio Restaurants Restaurants near Amish Country Restaurants near Amish Country OH Read Reviews of Amish Country Mudd Valley Cafe & Creamery #2 of 4 Restaurants in Walnut Creek 205 reviews 2641 State Route 39 0 miles from Amish Country The owners of the Amish Door first poured coffee and served broasted chicken for dinner in March 1977. 4774 US 62 Ohio's oldest general store appropriately sits in the heart of Amish Country. As you drive by in downtown Berlin, you may notice the restaurant by the line out the door! I grew up in Amish Country. Note to OH residents: Please double-check business hours of Amish restaurants listed here. Website, Der Dutchman Restaurant in Walnut Creek fills your taste for Amish favorite foods serving breakfast, lunch and dinner with buffet and salad bar. For more information, click, 6838 Co Rd 203, Millersburg, OH 44654, USA. She is an Ohio native with a Bachelor of Science in Journalism from E.W. So embarassing! And if you know another local gem in Ohio we should feature, nominate it on our online form! However, the German-style cooking hung on in the family line, and my fathers mother was German, so that style was familiar to him, too. Ice been thinking about it for a few months and couldnt think of anyone or group of people who may get the most benefit from this other than a community as yours. saudervillage.org To learn more, visit their Facebook page, What appears to be a country home off a dirt road in Clarksville, Ohio is actually a delicious restaurant with incredible views. While visiting Holmes County and surrounds, youll find a plethora of baked goods and full dinners. Hope. Free samples are available throughout the store to try and enjoy before buying! This interactive farm features more than 500 animals, including a beautiful herd of giraffes. You won't find them in some of the other big touristy restaurants. Stopped in to grab a meal to go. There were a couple other things we tried there, but now we just go and share the appetizer. White Oak Inn 2023. oldedutch.com A local favorite since 1938, the restaurant serves up delicious Amish-style meals in a down-home atmosphere. Berlin Farmstead Visit Berlin Farmstead 4757 Township Rd 366, Millersburg, OH, USA Get Directions Virtual Tour Contact Phone 330-893-4600 Hours Restaurant | Carry-Out Monday - Thursday: 11 am - 7 pm Friday - Saturday: 7 am - 8 pm Sunday: Closed Follow Us Come and Join Us Oh My, Pie! It has a real small hometown feel to it, although they are a very busy restaurant. Man, I loved that place! Very funny GreyCatz, The bakery is a must visit for your sweet tooth and carries a large selection of delicious cakes, cupcakes, donuts, pies, fritters, breads and more. Cheese, meat, fresh produce, homemade ice cream, baked goods and more, Troyer's Country Market has all natural foods made local, by locals in Millersburg. In Hartville,Ohio a good one is Hartville Kitchen & when there visit the Hartville Hardware & The Marketplace which is a nice flea market on Monday, Thursday, Friday & Saturday. Aaron Peachey Shisler's Cheese House, 55 Kidron Rd, Orrville, OH 44667, USA Have you been to any of these stores or markets before? The food was VERY reasonable and tasty. One of the best ways to experience Ohios untouched beauty is to visit one of the charming Amish villages. We also love going to the Kidron Town and Country Store and Restaurant. Outdoor dining is available during the summer, where you'll watch Amish buggies clip-clop through the busy streets of downtown Walnut Creek. a) They write their names on the inside of the hat (not much use if theyre all called Miller), In fact, most were in France, only 1 was in the United States, Yountville, CA made the list. mrsyoderskitchen.com Sip & savor. Restaurants near Amish Country, Ohio on TripAdvisor: Find traveler reviews and candid photos of dining near Amish Country in Ohio, United States. If youve only stopped long enough to fill-up on Amish noodles and peanut butter spread, youre missing the main course. Worth a stop! Also, Bags IS open on Sundays a rarity in Holmes County. There are also Amish families living in Ashland and Knox counties. From the brewery to the local pub, you can choose what suits you. Old fashioned Amish-cooked dishes such as slow-cooked roast beef or turkey, real mashed potatoes, fresh salads, homemade bread and rolls. Huge selection, reasonable prices, lots of Amish customers. She makes a her apple pies with maple syrup in the crust which give it a distinct flavor. Middlebury and Wana Cup in Shipshewana. Das Dutch Haus Restaurant This is my first time posting, and I am thoroughly enjoying Amish America. To learn more, visit their website, For some of the best old-fashioned cooking in Ohio, be sure to check out this Amish Country gem.